STX TechnologiesSTX Technologies

Compare

Managed IT vs. In-House IT

Hire an internal IT person, or partner with a managed service provider? The math and the coverage usually favor an MSP for small teams.

Managed IT (MSP)In-House Hire
CostFraction of a salary, flat feeSalary + benefits + tools
CoverageA whole team, 24/7One person, business hours
Skill breadthSpecialists across security, cloud, networkingGeneralist; gaps in deep areas
Vacation / sick daysAlways coveredYou're exposed when they're out
Tools & licensingIncluded (RMM, EDR, etc.)You buy them separately

Managed IT (MSP) is best for

Businesses with 1–50 staff that need broad coverage without a big fixed cost.

In-House Hire is best for

Larger orgs with constant, specialized, on-site needs — often paired with an MSP (co-managed).

The verdict

For most small businesses, an MSP delivers more coverage and skill for less than one salary. Growing teams often go co-managed — an internal person plus an MSP.

Run the real numbers

A single in-house IT hire isn't just a salary. Add benefits, payroll taxes, recruiting, training, and the tools they need — RMM, EDR, backup, ticketing, documentation — and the fully-loaded cost climbs well past the headline number. An MSP spreads those tools and a whole team across many clients, so you get them for a predictable fraction of one salary.

The gap widens when you account for coverage. One person works business hours and takes vacations; an MSP covers nights, weekends, and sick days without a second thought.

Coverage and skill breadth

No single hire is an expert in security, networking, cloud, Microsoft 365, and help desk all at once. An MSP brings specialists across each area, so you're not betting your whole operation on one person's knowledge — or scrambling when they leave and take it with them.

That said, an in-house person brings something valuable: deep context on your business and a face in the building. That's why many growing companies don't choose one or the other.

The co-managed middle ground

Co-managed IT keeps your internal person and adds an MSP behind them — tools, specialist help, after-hours coverage, and a backstop when they're out. It's often the best of both: institutional knowledge in-house, depth and coverage from the MSP. It's the natural model once a business grows past the point where one person can keep up.

Want a recommendation for your business?

Start with a free, no-obligation assessment.